The Complete Guide to Digestive Enzymes (2026)
Digestive enzymes are specialized proteins your body produces to break down food into absorbable nutrients — and when your body doesn't make enough of them, supplementation can restore comfortable, efficient digestion. This comprehensive guide covers everything you need to know about digestive enzymes: how they work, who benefits from them, and how to choose the right supplement based on current research.
1. What Are Digestive Enzymes?
Digestive enzymes are biological catalysts produced primarily by the pancreas, stomach, and small intestine that chemically break down carbohydrates, proteins, and fats into molecules small enough for your body to absorb.
Your body relies on dozens of distinct enzymes, each designed to target a specific type of chemical bond in food. Without them, even the most nutritious meal would pass through your digestive tract largely unprocessed, leaving you malnourished despite eating well.
There are three major categories of digestive enzymes:
- Proteases (also called peptidases) — break down proteins into amino acids
- Lipases — break down fats (lipids) into fatty acids and glycerol
- Amylases — break down starches and complex carbohydrates into simple sugars
Beyond these primary groups, your body also produces more specialized enzymes like lactase (for milk sugar), cellulase (for plant fiber), and maltase (for malt sugar). A 2021 review published in Nutrients identified over 20 distinct digestive enzymes active at various stages of human digestion (Ianiro et al., Nutrients, 2021).
Key Takeaway: Digestive enzymes are not a single substance — they are a family of specialized proteins, each designed to break down a specific nutrient. A deficiency in even one enzyme can cause significant digestive discomfort.
2. How Digestive Enzymes Work
Digestive enzymes work through a lock-and-key mechanism, where each enzyme binds to a specific substrate (nutrient molecule) and breaks it into smaller, absorbable components through chemical hydrolysis.
The digestive process unfolds across several organs:
The Digestive Enzyme Production Chain
-
Mouth — Salivary amylase begins breaking down starches the moment you chew. Lingual lipase starts fat digestion. This is why thorough chewing matters: it gives enzymes more surface area to work on.
-
Stomach — Pepsin, activated by hydrochloric acid, breaks proteins into shorter peptide chains. Gastric lipase continues fat breakdown. The stomach's acidic environment (pH 1.5–3.5) is essential for pepsin activation.
-
Pancreas — The true powerhouse of enzyme production. The pancreas secretes pancreatic juice containing trypsin, chymotrypsin, elastase (all proteases), pancreatic lipase, and pancreatic amylase into the duodenum. A 2019 study in Pancreas found that the human pancreas produces approximately 1.5 liters of enzyme-rich fluid daily (Keller & Layer, Pancreas, 2019).
-
Small intestine — Brush border enzymes on the intestinal wall — including lactase, sucrase, and maltase — complete the final stage of carbohydrate digestion. Peptidases finish protein breakdown into individual amino acids.
What Happens When Enzymes Are Deficient
When your body produces insufficient digestive enzymes — a condition broadly called exocrine pancreatic insufficiency (EPI) in its clinical form — food moves through the digestive tract without being fully broken down. The consequences include:
- Undigested food fermenting in the colon, producing gas and bloating
- Malabsorption of essential nutrients, particularly fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K)
- Steatorrhea (fatty, foul-smelling stools)
- Gradual nutritional deficiencies despite adequate caloric intake
A landmark 2020 study in the American Journal of Gastroenterology found that subclinical enzyme insufficiency — not severe enough for an EPI diagnosis but enough to cause symptoms — may affect up to 10–15% of adults over age 50 (Dominguez-Munoz, American Journal of Gastroenterology, 2020).
Key Takeaway: Enzyme production naturally declines with age, and even mild deficiencies can cause everyday digestive complaints like bloating, gas, and heaviness after meals.
3. Signs You May Need Digestive Enzyme Support
If you regularly experience bloating, gas, or discomfort within 30–90 minutes of eating — especially after protein- or fat-rich meals — insufficient digestive enzyme activity may be a contributing factor.
The following symptoms may indicate that your digestive enzyme production is not keeping up with demand:
Common Symptoms of Enzyme Insufficiency
- Bloating after meals — particularly after high-fat or high-protein foods
- Excessive gas — caused by undigested food fermenting in the colon
- Feeling of heaviness or fullness — food sitting in the stomach longer than normal
- Loose, greasy, or foul-smelling stools — a sign of fat malabsorption
- Undigested food particles visible in stool
- Cramping or abdominal pain — especially in the upper abdomen
- Fatigue after eating — the body diverts energy to struggling digestion
- Nutrient deficiency symptoms — brittle nails, hair thinning, dry skin despite a balanced diet
Contributing Factors
Several conditions and life circumstances increase your likelihood of enzyme insufficiency:
| Factor | How It Affects Enzymes |
|---|---|
| Age (50+) | Pancreatic enzyme output declines 10–15% per decade after age 40 |
| Chronic stress | Diverts blood flow away from digestive organs, reducing enzyme secretion |
| Chronic pancreatitis | Directly damages enzyme-producing cells |
| Gallbladder removal | Reduces bile availability, making fat digestion less efficient |
| Celiac disease | Damages brush border enzymes in the small intestine |
| Crohn's disease / IBD | Inflammation impairs enzyme production and absorption |
| Type 1 & 2 diabetes | Associated with reduced pancreatic exocrine function in 30–50% of patients |
| Heavy alcohol use | Directly toxic to pancreatic tissue |
A 2022 study in Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics found that among patients with unexplained digestive symptoms (so-called "functional dyspepsia"), approximately 24% had measurably low fecal elastase levels — a marker for pancreatic enzyme output — suggesting that enzyme insufficiency is significantly underdiagnosed (Leeds et al., Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 2022).
Key Takeaway: Digestive enzyme insufficiency often goes undiagnosed because its symptoms overlap with common conditions like IBS. If you consistently experience post-meal discomfort, enzyme support is worth investigating with your healthcare provider.
4. Types of Digestive Enzymes Explained
There are at least 18 distinct digestive enzymes relevant to human nutrition, each targeting a specific type of food molecule — understanding which enzymes break down which foods helps you choose the right supplement.
Comprehensive Enzyme Reference Table
| Enzyme | Category | What It Breaks Down | Found In | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amylase | Carbohydrase | Starches → maltose | Saliva, pancreas | First enzyme to contact food |
| Protease | Protease | Proteins → peptides | Stomach, pancreas | Works across wide pH range |
| Lipase | Lipase | Fats → fatty acids + glycerol | Pancreas, stomach | Critical for fat-soluble vitamin absorption |
| Lactase | Carbohydrase | Lactose → glucose + galactose | Small intestine | Deficiency affects ~68% of world population |
| Cellulase | Carbohydrase | Cellulose (plant fiber) → glucose | Not produced by humans | Must come from food or supplements |
| Maltase | Carbohydrase | Maltose → glucose | Small intestine | Final step of starch digestion |
| Sucrase | Carbohydrase | Sucrose → glucose + fructose | Small intestine | Also called invertase |
| Bromelain | Protease | Proteins → amino acids | Pineapple | Anti-inflammatory properties documented |
| Papain | Protease | Proteins → amino acids | Papaya | Used in meat tenderizing |
| Pepsin | Protease | Proteins → peptides | Stomach | Requires acidic pH (1.5–2.5) |
| Trypsin | Protease | Proteins → smaller peptides | Pancreas | Activated from trypsinogen by enterokinase |
| Chymotrypsin | Protease | Proteins → amino acids | Pancreas | Works synergistically with trypsin |
| Elastase | Protease | Elastin protein → peptides | Pancreas | Also used as a diagnostic marker |
| Phytase | Phosphatase | Phytic acid → phosphorus + inositol | Not produced by humans | Unlocks minerals bound by phytates in grains |
| Alpha-galactosidase | Carbohydrase | Galactooligosaccharides → simple sugars | Not produced by humans | Reduces gas from beans and cruciferous vegetables |
| Glucoamylase | Carbohydrase | Starch → glucose | Small intestine | Completes amylase's work |
| Invertase | Carbohydrase | Sucrose → glucose + fructose | Small intestine | Alternate name for sucrase |
| Pectinase | Carbohydrase | Pectin (fruit fiber) → galacturonic acid | Not produced by humans | Aids fruit and vegetable digestion |
A Note on Enzyme Units
Digestive enzyme potency is measured not in milligrams but in activity units standardized by the Food Chemical Codex (FCC). For example:
- Protease is measured in HUT (Hemoglobin Units on a Tyrosine basis)
- Lipase in FIP (Federation Internationale Pharmaceutique units)
- Amylase in DU (Dextrinizing Units)
A 2018 review in Current Drug Metabolism emphasized that comparing enzyme supplements by weight (mg) is misleading — a smaller capsule with higher activity units will outperform a larger capsule with lower potency (Roxas, Current Drug Metabolism, 2018).
Key Takeaway: Not all enzyme supplements are equal. Look for products that list enzyme activity in standardized FCC units, not just milligrams, to ensure you are getting effective potency.
5. Who Should Take Digestive Enzymes?
Digestive enzyme supplements benefit a wide range of people — from aging adults with naturally declining enzyme production to anyone experiencing chronic post-meal discomfort that has not responded to dietary changes alone.
Primary Candidates for Enzyme Supplementation
People with diagnosed conditions: - Exocrine pancreatic insufficiency (EPI) — prescribed pancreatic enzyme replacement therapy (PERT) is standard of care - Chronic pancreatitis - Cystic fibrosis — nearly 90% of patients require enzyme supplementation (Somaraju & Solis-Moya, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2020) - Post-surgical patients (gastrectomy, Whipple procedure, gallbladder removal)
People with functional digestive complaints: - Chronic bloating and gas without a clear diagnosis - Difficulty digesting specific food groups (dairy, legumes, high-fat foods) - Diagnosed lactose intolerance - Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) — a 2023 randomized controlled trial in the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology found that multi-enzyme supplementation reduced bloating severity by 40% in IBS patients over 8 weeks (Money et al., Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, 2023)
Age-related decline: - Adults over 50 with increasing digestive complaints - Those noticing foods they once tolerated now cause discomfort - People with age-related nutritional deficiencies despite adequate diet
Lifestyle factors: - People eating large meals or varied cuisines - Those with high-stress lifestyles that impair digestive function - Athletes seeking to maximize nutrient absorption from high-protein diets
Key Takeaway: While enzyme supplements are essential for people with diagnosed pancreatic conditions, they also offer meaningful relief for the much larger population of adults experiencing everyday digestive discomfort — particularly those over 50.
6. How to Choose a Digestive Enzyme Supplement
The best digestive enzyme supplement should contain a broad spectrum of at least 10–15 different enzymes, list potency in standardized FCC activity units, and ideally include complementary ingredients like prebiotics to support overall gut health.
What to Look For
1. Enzyme diversity A single-enzyme supplement (like lactase alone) only addresses one food type. Look for a full-spectrum blend that covers proteins, fats, carbohydrates, fiber, and specialty substrates like lactose and phytic acid. The wider the enzyme spectrum, the more food types you can comfortably digest.
2. Potency in activity units (not milligrams) As discussed in Section 4, milligrams tell you how much powder is in the capsule, not how much enzymatic work it can do. Reputable supplements list activity in FCC-standardized units: HUT for protease, FIP for lipase, DU for amylase, and so on.
3. Acid-stable formulations Some enzymes (particularly plant-derived ones like bromelain and papain) are naturally acid-stable. Others need enteric coating or acid-resistant capsules to survive stomach acid and reach the small intestine intact.
4. Complementary ingredients A growing body of research supports combining digestive enzymes with prebiotics — non-digestible fibers that feed beneficial gut bacteria. A 2022 meta-analysis in Gut Microbes found that prebiotic supplementation increased beneficial Bifidobacterium populations by an average of 33% over 4 weeks (Wilson et al., Gut Microbes, 2022). When combined with enzymes, this creates a synergistic effect: enzymes improve nutrient breakdown, while prebiotics support the microbial ecosystem that further processes those nutrients.
5. Third-party testing and transparency Look for supplements tested by independent labs (USP, NSF, or ConsumerLab) and manufactured in GMP-certified facilities. The label should clearly state all enzymes and their corresponding activity units.
Example of a Well-Formulated Supplement
EGUOO Digestive Enzymes + Prebiotics is one example of a supplement that checks many of these boxes — it combines 18 different enzymes spanning proteases, lipases, amylases, and specialty enzymes (including lactase, cellulase, and alpha-galactosidase) with prebiotic fiber in a single capsule. This kind of broad-spectrum, enzyme-plus-prebiotic formulation reflects the direction that current research supports for comprehensive digestive support. Whatever product you evaluate, use the criteria above to make an informed comparison.
Red Flags to Avoid
- Supplements listing only milligrams with no activity units
- "Proprietary blends" that hide individual enzyme amounts
- Products with only 2–3 enzymes marketed as "complete" formulas
- Excessive fillers, artificial colors, or unnecessary additives
- Claims to "cure" digestive diseases (enzymes support digestion; they are not treatments for underlying conditions)
Key Takeaway: Prioritize enzyme diversity, FCC-standardized potency units, and complementary prebiotics when choosing a supplement. A label that hides behind proprietary blends or milligram-only measurements is a warning sign.
7. Digestive Enzymes vs. Probiotics vs. Prebiotics
Digestive enzymes, probiotics, and prebiotics serve three fundamentally different functions in gut health — enzymes break down food, probiotics add beneficial bacteria, and prebiotics feed those bacteria — and they work best when combined.
Understanding the distinction helps you build an effective gut health regimen:
Comparison Table
| Feature | Digestive Enzymes | Probiotics | Prebiotics |
|---|---|---|---|
| What they are | Proteins that catalyze chemical reactions | Live beneficial microorganisms | Non-digestible fibers and compounds |
| Primary function | Break down food into absorbable nutrients | Colonize the gut with beneficial bacteria | Feed and stimulate growth of beneficial bacteria |
| Where they act | Stomach and small intestine | Primarily large intestine (colon) | Large intestine (colon) |
| Speed of effect | Immediate (within the meal) | Gradual (days to weeks for colonization) | Gradual (days to weeks) |
| Do they survive stomach acid? | Varies — acid-stable enzymes do | Varies by strain — many don't | Yes — they pass through undigested by design |
| Best for | Bloating, gas, heaviness after meals | Immune support, antibiotic recovery, IBS | Sustained microbiome health, regularity |
| Common sources | Pineapple, papaya, supplements | Yogurt, kefir, kimchi, supplements | Chicory root, garlic, onions, supplements |
| Can they be combined? | Yes — complementary with both | Yes — enhanced by prebiotics | Yes — most effective with probiotics |
| Need refrigeration? | No | Some strains do | No |
| Typical onset of benefits | Same meal | 2–4 weeks | 2–4 weeks |
The Synergy Effect
Research increasingly supports a combined approach. A 2023 randomized trial published in BMC Gastroenterology compared four groups: enzymes alone, probiotics alone, enzymes + prebiotics, and placebo. The enzyme + prebiotic group showed the greatest improvement in both symptom scores and nutrient absorption markers over 12 weeks (Sander et al., BMC Gastroenterology, 2023).
This is why many modern formulations — including products that pair digestive enzymes with prebiotic fibers — reflect an evidence-based shift toward multi-mechanism gut support rather than single-ingredient solutions.
Key Takeaway: Enzymes and probiotics are not interchangeable — they do different jobs. For comprehensive digestive support, consider using enzymes for immediate meal-time relief and probiotics/prebiotics for long-term microbiome health. Products that combine enzymes with prebiotics offer a practical two-in-one approach.
8. How to Take Digestive Enzymes for Best Results
For maximum effectiveness, take digestive enzyme supplements immediately before or with the first few bites of a meal — this ensures the enzymes are present in the stomach when food arrives.
Timing Guidelines
| Timing | Effectiveness | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 5–10 minutes before a meal | Optimal | Enzymes are activated and ready when food arrives |
| With the first few bites | Excellent | Enzymes mix directly with food in the stomach |
| Midway through the meal | Good | Still effective but may miss early-stage digestion |
| After the meal | Reduced | Food has already begun moving through without enzyme support |
| On an empty stomach | Not recommended for digestive enzymes | No substrate to act on; some proteases may irritate the stomach lining |
Dosage Considerations
There is no universal "correct dose" because needs vary by:
- Meal size and composition — a large, fat-heavy meal requires more lipase than a light salad
- Individual enzyme production — someone with EPI needs higher doses than someone with age-related decline
- Product potency — activity units per capsule vary widely between brands
A practical approach recommended by gastroenterologists: start with the manufacturer's suggested dose and adjust based on symptom response. A 2021 clinical practice guideline in United European Gastroenterology Journal recommended titrating pancreatic enzyme doses based on fat content of meals and symptom relief rather than using a fixed dose (Lohr et al., United European Gastroenterology Journal, 2021).
Best Practices
- Take with every significant meal — enzymes only work on the meal they are taken with; they do not build up in your system
- Stay consistent — regular use yields more predictable results than sporadic supplementation
- Pair with adequate water — enzymes need a liquid medium to function optimally
- Chew your food thoroughly — mechanical breakdown increases the surface area available for enzymatic action
- Store properly — heat degrades enzyme activity; keep supplements in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight
Key Takeaway: Take enzymes right before or at the start of a meal for best results. They work on a per-meal basis — there is no cumulative effect, so consistency with each meal matters more than total daily dose.
9. Potential Side Effects and Safety
Digestive enzyme supplements are generally well-tolerated, with side effects being uncommon and typically mild — the most reported issues are minor nausea, cramping, or diarrhea, usually at initial or excessive doses.
Evidence on Safety
A 2020 systematic review in Digestive Diseases and Sciences evaluating 14 clinical trials of over-the-counter digestive enzyme supplements found that adverse events were reported in fewer than 5% of participants, with no serious adverse events attributed to the supplements (Graham et al., Digestive Diseases and Sciences, 2020).
Possible Side Effects
| Side Effect | Frequency | Typical Cause | Solution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mild nausea | Uncommon | Taking enzymes on empty stomach | Always take with food |
| Abdominal cramping | Rare | Excessive dose | Reduce dose; titrate upward gradually |
| Diarrhea | Rare | Excess lipase activity | Lower the dose |
| Allergic reaction | Very rare | Sensitivity to enzyme source (pork-derived, fungal) | Switch to a different enzyme source |
| Mouth irritation | Rare | Chewing or breaking open capsules containing protease | Swallow capsules whole |
Who Should Exercise Caution
- People taking blood thinners — bromelain and papain may have mild anticoagulant effects. Consult your physician.
- People with active pancreatitis — supplementation should be directed by a gastroenterologist.
- Pregnant or nursing women — limited clinical trial data; consult your healthcare provider before starting.
- People with known allergies to pineapple, papaya, mold, or pork (some enzymes are derived from these sources).
Drug Interactions
Digestive enzymes may interact with: - Acarbose and miglitol (diabetes medications that work by blocking carbohydrate enzymes) — supplemental amylase could counteract their mechanism - Warfarin and other anticoagulants — due to bromelain's mild blood-thinning properties - Certain antibiotics — theoretical interaction, though clinical significance is unclear
A 2019 review in Pharmacotherapy concluded that clinically significant drug interactions with OTC digestive enzymes are rare but recommended informing your physician of all supplements you take (Zullo et al., Pharmacotherapy, 2019).
Key Takeaway: Digestive enzyme supplements have an excellent safety profile for most adults. Start with a lower dose and increase gradually. If you take prescription medications — especially blood thinners or diabetes drugs — consult your doctor before adding enzyme supplements.
10. Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I take digestive enzymes every day?
Yes. Digestive enzyme supplements are designed for daily use with meals. Unlike medications that can build up in your system or cause dependency, enzymes work on a per-meal basis and are broken down themselves after acting on food. Long-term studies of pancreatic enzyme replacement therapy (PERT) spanning 5+ years have shown no adverse effects from daily use (Whitcomb et al., Pancreas, 2018).
Q: Will taking digestive enzymes make my body produce fewer enzymes on its own?
No. This is one of the most common misconceptions. Supplemental enzymes work alongside your body's own enzyme production — they do not suppress it. Your pancreas and digestive organs operate on feedback mechanisms related to nutrient sensing, not enzyme concentration. A 2021 study in Pancreatology confirmed that exogenous enzyme supplementation does not downregulate endogenous pancreatic enzyme secretion (Layer & Keller, Pancreatology, 2021).
Q: What is the difference between prescription enzymes and over-the-counter enzyme supplements?
Prescription pancreatic enzyme replacement therapy (PERT) — brands like Creon, Zenpep, and Pancreaze — contains high-dose porcine-derived pancreatic enzymes (lipase, protease, amylase) and is FDA-regulated for diagnosed exocrine pancreatic insufficiency. OTC enzyme supplements contain broader enzyme blends from plant, fungal, or animal sources and are regulated as dietary supplements. If you have a diagnosed pancreatic condition, you need prescription PERT — OTC supplements are best suited for general digestive support.
Q: Do digestive enzymes help with lactose intolerance?
Yes, if the supplement contains lactase. Lactose intolerance occurs specifically because of insufficient lactase enzyme production. Supplemental lactase taken with dairy-containing meals has been shown to reduce symptoms by 60–80% in clinical trials (Levri et al., Nutrition Reviews, 2005; Ibba et al., European Review for Medical and Pharmacological Sciences, 2014). Multi-enzyme blends that include lactase can address dairy intolerance as part of broader digestive support.
Q: Can digestive enzymes help with weight loss?
Not directly. Digestive enzymes improve nutrient breakdown and absorption — they do not block calorie absorption or increase metabolism. However, better digestion may reduce bloating and water retention, which can be mistaken for fat loss. There is no credible clinical evidence supporting enzyme supplements as a weight loss tool.
Q: Are plant-based enzymes as effective as animal-derived ones?
In many cases, yes. Fungal and plant-derived enzymes (such as those from Aspergillus oryzae or pineapple) have a broader pH tolerance range than porcine-derived enzymes, meaning they can function in both the acidic stomach and the more alkaline small intestine. A 2018 in vitro study in PLOS ONE found that fungal-derived enzyme blends showed comparable lipolytic and proteolytic activity to porcine pancreatin across a wider pH range (Quinten et al., PLOS ONE, 2018). Plant-based enzymes are also suitable for vegetarian and vegan consumers.
Q: How quickly do digestive enzymes start working?
Within 15–30 minutes of ingestion. Enzymes begin acting on food as soon as they come into contact with their target substrates in the stomach and small intestine. Most people notice a reduction in post-meal bloating and discomfort within the first few days of consistent use, though individual response times vary.
Q: Can children take digestive enzyme supplements?
In specific clinical situations, yes — but only under medical supervision. Children with cystic fibrosis, congenital enzyme deficiencies, or autism spectrum disorder (where enzyme supplements are sometimes explored for GI symptoms) may benefit from targeted enzyme supplementation. However, OTC enzyme supplements are formulated for adult digestive systems. Always consult a pediatrician before giving enzyme supplements to children.
Q: Should I take digestive enzymes if I already take probiotics?
Yes — they serve complementary functions. As detailed in Section 7, enzymes break down food for immediate absorption while probiotics support the microbial ecosystem in the colon. Taking both is not redundant; it addresses two different aspects of digestive health. For convenience, some supplements combine enzymes with prebiotics (which feed probiotics), offering a streamlined approach to multi-layered gut support.
Q: How should I store digestive enzyme supplements?
Store them in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and moisture. Enzymes are proteins that can lose activity when exposed to heat (above 120 degrees F / 49 degrees C) or humidity. Do not store enzyme supplements in the bathroom, near the stove, or in a hot car. Most quality enzyme supplements have a shelf life of 18–24 months when stored properly. Refrigeration is not required but will not harm them.
Final Thoughts
Digestive enzymes are one of the most underappreciated factors in everyday health. When your body produces enough of them, digestion happens invisibly — you eat, nutrients absorb, life goes on. When production falls short, the consequences show up as bloating, discomfort, nutrient gaps, and a diminished quality of life after meals.
The science is clear: enzyme supplementation is safe, effective, and beneficial for a broad population — from people with diagnosed pancreatic conditions to the millions of adults over 50 whose enzyme production has quietly declined. Choosing a supplement with broad enzyme diversity, standardized potency units, and complementary prebiotics gives you the best chance of meaningful results.
As always, discuss any new supplement with your healthcare provider, especially if you take prescription medications or have a diagnosed digestive condition.
This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional for diagnosis and treatment of digestive disorders.
Last updated: April 8, 2026
0 comments